Its A Wonderful Life

23 July 2006

mean Girls, Mean People

Yikes, I almost hate to admit to this, but I enjoyed Mean Girls and have mentioned it to my own 13 year old daughter & her friends, most of whom have not seen it. I guess I thought parts of it were way over the top and I felt a little "led" through the movie -- I don't like that at all. I did like most of the characters, even the ones who were overdrawn, like the mother. Unfortunately, I think I know a couple of women like her, whose dress and conversation does not gravitate far from the dress and conversation of their daughters. My comment about them is always that I already went through hight school, didn't much like it the first time and certainly would not want to repeat the experience!

The girls who were hanging around here last week feel (of course) that while there may be a click or two around school, it is more a matter of hanging out with people you are friends with or comfortable being around. I was looking at their clothing while they were talking and they were dressed pretty similarly with certain brands glaringly displayed. Is it that they dress alike, or is it that there are limited choices. A couple of the girls "shop" at the Salvation Army, but most are mall rats.
My daughter has preferences, but I can't quite figure them out -- she's not a follower, but is picky about color, texture, length and has old favorites she hangs on to long after they are out of style. She says she doesn't care, but I don't know if she is responding to me (I am a strong anti click/style/whatever) person or really feels this way.

I know these girls feel the tug and pull of one another and whomever the "popular" girl is at the time. This role does change hands and I can't figure out what the queen bee's power is based upon. AND, make no mistake about it, she is powerful, even if that power is fleeting. She seems able to make or break friendships, determine who will be invited to parties, who sits with whom at lunch. Then, for reasons I can't determine, there is a new "queen bee". There is lots of talk about this phenomenon between and amongst the girls and they, too, seem to not understand how this happens.

I get irked at their "victim" stance. We've talked about popularity, that it is about power and that power is given -- that they, in essence are giving the power to the popular person -- it seems to fall on deaf ears. Hmmmm.... No one seems willing or eager to dethrone the girls of the moment either. They more or less wait her out, deal with whatever hurts she inflicts and bemoan the situation amogst themselves.

Are they on some kind of learning curve here? Is this necessary to their full development as adult women, I don't know. I do sense that these girls, my own and her friends are amazingly resilient in this area. Not that there are no tears, but they are able to recover rapidly and with little evidence of any deeply inficted ache or pain. I think that's a positive, but again, I don't know.

I ordered a copy of Queen Bees and Wanna Be's for my August pile -- forwarned is forarmed!

4 Comments:

At 10:11 PM, Blogger plethoria said...

This post has been removed by a blog administrator.

 
At 10:14 PM, Blogger plethoria said...

One of your comments interested me: "Is it that teens dress alike, or is it that there are limited choices?" I often feel uncomfortable at seeing what teen [and pre-teen!] girls are wearing. I do think that mall culture plays a big role in the clothing choices of teens- if they just go to a mall, most of the clothing choices will be similar. Unfortunately, a lot of clothing for teen girls is quite suggestive and/or inappropriate. I don't consider myself to be a "conservative" or pro-censorship, but I am ultra-concerned about the development of teens today. I do think there needs to be a turnaround, in regard to the emphasis on clothing brands, logos, and material goods. I worry about the girls that we are raising today- the same issues affect boys too though. I saw this quote in a recent issue of NEA and think it says a lot about teens today: "My concern is that they [teens] think it is normal to have a $300 iPod or a $60 a month cell phone bill and have no idea how it gets paid for."

Thanks for your insightful post.

 
At 10:41 AM, Blogger librarywannabe said...

To me, there are many correlations between culture today and the culture described in FEED. Take away some of the more scifi stuff and we don't really seem to different than those folks described in the book, agree??

Shopping with my daughter is difficult. It seems we went from pretty cute and tomboyish styles which were perfect for her to rather (sorry) whore-ish styles that reveal a lot, send overt (sometimes even printed on shirts and pants) messages about who my daughter may be and frankly I wouldn't even buy for a much older daughter. I am far from conservative on most fronts, but aren't I her protector, at least for now? She does not choose these styles herself, but we are hard pressed to find other things and can spend hours and hours (and I HATE shopping) looking for a few pieces.

Boys do have it equally bad, especially my African American son. So many messages are being beemed at him about what is "cool". I remember when he started the sixth grade and had to have a pair of red converse high tops. There was no talking him out of them even though he knew they would be his everyday shoes. So, of course within a matter of weeks I find them outside and, of course in true parental fashion, admonish him for leaving them around (they were a fortune) and asking why, if he had to have them, he was not taking care of them.

His response? I looked right at me and said that in fact he didn't really want those shoes, but was thinking that if he had those shoes someone might actually be nice to him. I could have cried right there. How dumb I thought, not him, me!

No one escapes these times, some weather it better than others no doubt.

 
At 10:22 AM, Blogger DrCammack said...

I go back and forth on this issue too. I never thought of myself as conservative in terms of censoring how kids dress, but the sexuality of girls' clothing, especially at younger and younger ages concerns me. I think not only that it sends a message, but that the girls aren't necessarily truly interested in being as sexual as they may look and are mistaking sexual positioning for other kinds of connection. I don't know.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home